From where I’m sitting, in Phoenix, Az at the heart of the storm over Arizona’s new, controversial immigration law, the debate is literally raging outside my window. (Actually, right now they’re re-painting the building across the way from me, so the debate isn’t raging so much as it’s setting up painter’s tape around the building’s windows. But after that, it’s sure to start raging again).
The law makes it illegal to be in Arizona if you are not a legal immigrant, and gives police officers the power to confront someone they suspect of being illegal and ask about their immigration status. This has caused concern in two areas: One, does the state have the power to enforce immigration policy, or is that the business of the federal government? Two, might it lead to racial profiling if police are expected to spot those who appear to be here illegally?
I for one find the whole uproar silly. First, states should be allowed to do whatever they want whenever they want regardless of federal law. That’s why I firmly support certain southern states interests in succeeding from the union, and Wyoming’s long-held desire to allow people to drive on whatever side of the road they feel like it. If the Civil War taught us anything it’s that if states get to do whatever they want regardless of federal policy, nothing bad will ever happen. That’s just fact.
The second point is more complicated. Can police use means other than race to identify “suspiciously illegal” characters? Of course, if they know what to look for. For example, here are some traits almost all illegal immigrants share that have nothing at all to do with race:
- They are often shifty, not staying in one place for more than a few minutes. This is not, as some assume, a result of fear, but a biological quirk: If an illegal immigrant stands still for more than ten minutes he or she will die.
- Their bright yellow eyes, which have evolved to give them super night-vision
- The way they float when tossed into a body of water (if they sink, they were just a terrorist)
Luckily, it appears the end to the debate is in site. The pop-singer Shakira is on her way to Arizona to try and help resolve the situation. Some may wonder how a Grammy-winning singer is going to fix a problem as complex and contested as immigration, but those people don’t realize how beloved Shakira is in Arizona. She is literally a God here, with many mystery cults popping up in her honor. This is why when AZ finally releases it’s own currency next year (getting off the dreaded dollar-standard), Shakira will be on the newly minted $3 bill.







